AFCA Overrules Insurer in Camper Trailer Damage Case

0

Initially, the camper owner noticed no damage during usage in early November 2023, only to uncover water damage in April the following year. The insurer, RAA Insurance, asserted that the seals of the camper had deteriorated over time, thereby excluding it from coverage under clauses related to "depreciation, wear and tear, rust, corrosion," as well as "deteriorated seals and joints over a number of incidents."

The AFCA reviewed evidence from the insurer's assessor, which included images showing gaps in the seals where they did not align perfectly with the camper body. Despite these submissions, the authority found that the images and other evidence failed to incontrovertibly establish the alleged deterioration. They identified a lack of definitive indicators, such as holes or cracking, that would typically signal such decline.

In the ruling, an AFCA ombudsman remarked that, while deterioration is indeed a gradual process, the insurer did not provide persuasive evidence establishing that deterioration was the primary cause of the damage. The decision placed the burden of proof on the insurer, requiring clear information detailing the condition of the seals and how it led to the damage.

Consequently, AFCA mandated the insurer to approve the claim and arrange for repairs. Should they opt for a cash settlement, a 15% increase over the repair quotation must be paid. This decision underscores the obligation of insurers to substantiate exclusions in policy claims with compelling evidence.

Published:Monday, 9th Jun 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

AFCA Overrules Insurer in Camper Trailer Damage Case 09 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) has ruled that a camper trailer owner will receive coverage for water and mould damage after the insurer could not demonstrate that the wear and tear exclusions applied under the policy. The case emerged after a storm in November 2023, which the claimant says caused severe wind to rip the cover off the camper, allowing water ingress and subsequent mould development. - read more

Regulatory Bodies Demand Clarity on Duration-Based Insurance Premiums 06 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori Australia’s leading financial regulators, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) and the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA), have raised concerns regarding the practice of duration-based pricing in life insurance products. They have emphasised the need for insurers to improve transparency, ensuring that consumers are fully informed about the long-term costs associated with initial premium discounts. - read more

Young Driver Left Uncovered Due to Policy Misstep 05 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori A policyholder faces a denied claim after inadvertently excluding his newly licensed 21-year-old son from his car insurance policy, highlighting a common oversight in age-specific exclusions. Following a collision involving his son, who recently earned his licence, Hollard Insurance declined the claim based on policy terms that excluded drivers under 25, unless accompanied by a qualified adult. - read more

NSW Floods Highlight Critical Insurability Crisis 05 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori Recently, New South Wales has been severely affected by major floods, with damages to around 10,000 homes and businesses. The Insurance Council of Australia has already received over 6,000 claims from the Mid North Coast and Hunter regions, while countless families face displacement as their homes become uninhabitable. - read more

Ride-Share Driver Prevails in Insurance Dispute Over Vehicle Use 04 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori A ride-share driver recently won a significant claim dispute against an insurer that initially denied his claim following a traffic accident. The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) sided with the driver, determining that Auto & General could not prove he misrepresented his vehicle use when purchasing his insurance policy. - read more